Comparing Multiple Tools

Now you've tried Suno, Udio, and MusicGen, right? "So which one is best?" you're probably wondering.

The answer is... "It depends on the situation!" Each has clear pros and cons. Today we'll compare the three tools in depth and tell you clearly when to use which.

After reading this, you'll be able to choose the optimal tool for your situation!

Overall Comparison Summary - At a Glance

First, let's look at the overall comparison table. We'll explain each in detail below.

Feature	Suno	Udio	MusicGen
Price	Free/Monthly $10/$30	Free/Monthly $10/$30	Completely Free
Generation Speed	⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Fast	⭐⭐⭐⭐ Medium	⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Fast
Sound Quality	⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐	⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐	⭐⭐⭐⭐
Vocal Quality	⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐	⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐	❌ None
Max Length	4 min (extendable)	4 min+ (easy extend)	30 sec
Customization	⭐⭐⭐⭐	⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐	⭐⭐⭐
Commercial Use	Paid Plan	Paid Plan	Check License
Korean Support	⭐⭐⭐⭐	⭐⭐⭐⭐	❌
Ease of Use	⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Easy	⭐⭐⭐⭐ Medium	⭐⭐⭐ Medium

Suno In-Depth Analysis

Greatest Strengths

1. Ease of Use

Pros:
- Intuitive interface
- Fast learning curve
- Optimal for beginners

2. Vocal Quality

Features:
- Natural pronunciation
- Excellent emotional expression
- Various vocal styles

3. Generation Speed

Average generation time:
- 1-2 minutes (2 versions)
- Immediate results
- Fast iterative work

Weaknesses

1. Lack of Fine Control

Limitations:
- Hard to modify specific sections
- Can't adjust by instrument
- Limited structure changes

2. Credit System

Free plan:
- 50 credits per month
- 1 song = 10 credits
- 5 songs per month limit

Optimal Suno Use Cases

1. Fast Prototyping

Usage scenarios:
- Idea sketching
- Demo creation
- Mood testing

2. Songs with Lyrics

Strengths:
- High-quality vocals
- Lyric delivery
- Various genres

3. Non-professional Composition

Target:
- OK without music theory
- Hobby creation
- Need fast results

Suno Pro Tips

Tip 1: Prompt Optimization

Basic:
"Sad song"

Improved:
"Melancholic piano ballad, emotional female vocals, slow tempo, heartbreaking"

Tip 2: Use Custom Mode

In Custom mode:
1. Clearly specify style
2. Divide lyric sections
3. Specify special effects

Tip 3: Continuous Generation

When you find a song you like:
1. Use "Continue" feature
2. Generate longer version
3. Create variations

Udio In-Depth Analysis

Greatest Strengths

1. Musical Completion

Features:
- Complex arrangements
- Delicate details
- Professional sound

2. Extension and Editing

Functions:
- Extend (lengthen track)
- Remix (rearrange)
- Inpaint (partial modification)

3. Community

Pros:
- Active sharing
- Browse excellent works
- Abundant references

Weaknesses

1. Generation Time

Cons:
- Slower than Suno
- Waiting time exists
- Delays when server busy

2. Learning Curve

Difficulty:
- Various options
- Many features
- Can confuse beginners

Optimal Udio Use Cases

1. High-Quality Music Production

Usage scenarios:
- Final products
- Commercial projects
- Portfolio pieces

2. Long Track Creation

Pros:
- Easy extension
- Natural development
- Combine multiple sections

3. Detailed Editing

Functions:
- Regenerate specific sections
- Change style
- Gradual improvement

Udio Pro Tips

Tip 1: Use Tag System

Prompt:
"Cinematic, emotional, strings, piano, dramatic build-up, [epic], [heartfelt]"

Can emphasize with tags

Tip 2: Extend Strategy

Creating long tracks:
1. Generate 32-second base
2. Add intro with Extend
3. Add outro with Extend
4. Expand middle sections as needed

Tip 3: Use References

In Explore:
1. Find songs you like
2. Reference prompts
3. Generate similar styles

MusicGen In-Depth Analysis

Greatest Strengths

1. Completely Free

Pros:
- No credit limits
- Unlimited generation
- Good for experimentation

2. Open Source

Features:
- Can run locally
- Code customization
- API usage possible

3. Fast Generation

Speed:
- 10-20 second generation time
- Immediate testing
- Efficient iterative work

Weaknesses

1. Short Length

Limitation:
- Maximum 30 seconds
- Can't make long tracks
- Loop-focused

2. No Vocals

Limitation:
- Pure instrumental only
- No lyrics possible
- Background music only

3. Sound Quality

Cons:
- Lower than Suno/Udio
- Occasional distortion
- Lacks delicacy

Optimal MusicGen Use Cases

1. Background Music (BGM)

Use:
- YouTube backgrounds
- Game music
- App sounds

2. Music Loops

Utilization:
- Repeat playback
- Beat creation
- Sampling source

3. Fast Experimentation

Pros:
- Test ideas
- Compare styles
- Unlimited attempts

MusicGen Pro Tips

Tip 1: Short and Clear Prompts

Good example:
"Upbeat electronic dance music, energetic"

Bad example:
"Very complex and emotional cinematic orchestral piece with many instruments"

Tip 2: Optimize Duration

Recommendations:
- 10-15 seconds: Short loops
- 20-25 seconds: Complete theme
- 30 seconds: Maximum length

Tip 3: Model Selection

Melody model:
- More melodic
- Memorable tunes

Large model:
- More complex arrangements
- Higher quality

Real Comparison: Same Prompt, Different Results

Test 1: Emotional Piano Piece

Common Prompt:

Emotional piano piece, melancholic, slow tempo, beautiful

Suno Result:

• Generation time: 1 min 30 sec
• Length: 3 min 20 sec
• Features: Vocals added (unwanted)
• Quality: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Udio Result:

• Generation time: 2 min 30 sec
• Length: 2 min (extendable)
• Features: Pure piano, clean
• Quality: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

MusicGen Result:

• Generation time: 15 sec
• Length: 30 sec
• Features: Basic piano
• Quality: ⭐⭐⭐

Conclusion:

• Short BGM → MusicGen
• High-quality track → Udio
• Fast prototype → Suno

Test 2: Upbeat Pop Song (with lyrics)

Prompt:

Upbeat pop song, energetic, catchy chorus, happy vibes

[Verse]
Dancing in the sunshine
Everything feels so right
Living in the moment
This is our time

[Chorus]
We're alive tonight
Shining so bright
Nothing can stop us now

Suno Result:

• Perfect vocals
• Natural lyric delivery
• Catchy melody
• Score: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Udio Result:

• Professional vocals
• Polished production
• Slightly longer generation time
• Score: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

MusicGen Result:

• Impossible (no vocals)
• Score: ❌

Conclusion: Songs with lyrics only possible with Suno or Udio

Test 3: YouTube Intro (10 seconds)

Prompt:

10-second energetic intro music, electronic, catchy

Suno Result:

• Generates minimum 2 minutes (editing needed)
• High quality but inefficient
• Score: ⭐⭐⭐

Udio Result:

• Generates 32 seconds (editing needed)
• Good results when edited
• Score: ⭐⭐⭐⭐

MusicGen Result:

• Can generate exactly 10 seconds
• Ready to use immediately
• Score: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Conclusion: MusicGen optimal for short intros

Recommended Tools by Situation

Beginners

Recommend: Suno
Reasons:
- Easiest
- Fast results
- Intuitive

Need Professional Results

Recommend: Udio
Reasons:
- Highest quality
- Fine-tuned adjustment
- Long tracks possible

Background Music Production

Recommend: MusicGen
Reasons:
- Free unlimited
- Fast generation
- Short loops

Songs with Lyrics

Recommend: Suno or Udio
Reasons:
- Vocal quality
- Natural delivery
- Various styles

Experimentation and Learning

Recommend: MusicGen → Suno → Udio order
Reasons:
- Practice for free
- Gradual learning
- Difficulty adjustment

Cost-Benefit

Free Users

Suno: 5 songs per month
Udio: 10 songs per month (more credits)
MusicGen: Unlimited

Recommend: Practice with MusicGen, final work with Suno/Udio

$10 Investment

Suno Pro: 500 songs per month
Udio Standard: 1,200 songs per month

Recommend: Udio (more generations possible)

Professional ($30)

Suno Premier: Unlimited + commercial use
Udio Pro: Unlimited + priority generation

Recommend: Choose based on use
- Fast work → Suno
- High quality → Udio

Combined Usage Strategies

Strategy 1: Prototype → Completion

1. Test ideas with MusicGen
2. Create fast version with Suno
3. Final completion with Udio

Strategy 2: Role Division

BGM: MusicGen
Intro/Outro: Suno
Main tracks: Udio

Strategy 3: Layering

1. Generate beat with MusicGen
2. Generate melody with Suno
3. Combine in audio editor

Practice Assignments

Assignment 1: 3-Way Comparison

Use all three tools with same prompt:

Prompt: "Chill lofi hip-hop, relaxed beat"

Compare items:
- Generation time
- Sound quality
- Ease of use
- Final preference

Assignment 2: Find Optimal Tool

Choose tool matching your project:

Questions:
1. What kind of music will you create?
2. Budget?
3. How often will you use it?
4. Need vocals?
5. Track length?

Assignment 3: Combination Project

Complete using multiple tools:

Example:
1. Drum loop with MusicGen
2. Main melody with Suno
3. Combine in editing program

Next Time Preview

Now that you've mastered all the tools, it's time to organize your works. Next time we'll learn how to bundle your created songs into an album and present them professionally!

---

TIP: Don't stick to just one tool. Understanding each tool's pros and cons and choosing based on situation is the best strategy. Start free and consider paid plans as needed!